Greta Thunberg & Her Detractors: The “Exceptionalist” Narrative and the Psychology of Climate Denial – Pt. 1 | EV & N #327 | CCTV

20191006-EV&N-327a-w500

http://ecoethics.net/2014-ENVRE120/20191006-EV&N-327-Link.html

https://www.cctvcambridge.org/node/666891

YouTube Version

Greta Thunberg has a clear messge, but some climate change denialists are trying hard to discredit her voice.   In the process, however, they demonstrate their own ignorance and complete lack of understanding of both Greta Thunberg’s message about the central importance of science and the broader climate movement she has inspired among youth around the world.

Her accomplishment stands out in stark relief to the myopia of her detractors.  She has inspired tens of millions of students across the globe to ask the obvious question:  What good is schooling if the prospects for human survival are rapidly collapsing and may not afford them any future worth living.  As she points out because of the mindless pursuit of endless growth strategies by corporations and corporate-states national policies are driving increased fossil fuel consumption all around the world just when every school student has learned in elementary science classes that this will destroy civilization as we know it.  What use, they ask (quite reasonably) is further education if all it leads to is making extinction more efficient.  Surely, they assert, shouldn’t we all be engaged in emergency action to get off our dependence on fossil fuels that are killing the prospect for a survivable future for everyone.

Greta’s critics have clearly lost the argument.   They have been reduced to repeating textual passages recorded by scribes in the late bronze-age in the Palestinian hill country.  They act as if those “sacred” texts indicate that humans will be exceptions to the oncoming climate catastrophes because their “God” is reputed to have “promised” that the global ice caps will not melt and flood the world’s coastlines.

20191006-EV&N-327-insert

The sweeping scope of this arrogance is truly breathtaking.  One is reminded of St. Augustine’s observation, often cited by the Reverend William Sloane, Coffin, Jr.

“We humans never do evil more cheerfully than when we do it in the name of God.”

Sadly, this combination of ignorance and arrogance has been the major theme of Republican political figures for decades, many of whom have claimed personal and privileged divine guidance in arriving at their political decisions:

bush-jesus2

Yale Class of 1968
43rd President of the United States

January 20, 2001 – January 20, 2009

See related:

The more direct connection between the political right and the white evangelicals has been discussed elsewhere.

For many who believe they will be “saved” when the armageddon comes, there is a feeling that the devastation that is anticipated from coming changes in climate may actually be beneficial since it will hasten the arrival of the moment of salvation for the “chosen people.”  Since the “chosen people” will be exceptions to the devastation wrought upon the Earth in general, ominous climate news actually under girds their “exceptionalist” religious narrative about those who will be “saved.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s